A judge brings their gavel down on a sound block during a personal injury court case.

Can I Settle My Personal Injury Claim Without Going to Court?

Settling your personal injury claim without going to court is not only common in Tennessee, but it also offers several advantages. Discover the benefits of settling out of court, important considerations to keep in mind, and situations where going to trial may be necessary. Learn more about navigating the settlement process for your personal injury claim here.

Get a FREE Case Review

"*" indicates required fields

Settling a Personal Injury Claim Outside of Court in Tennessee

In Tennessee, individuals who have suffered a personal injury typically wonder whether they can settle their claims without going through a court trial. The answer is yes. In fact, the majority of personal injury cases in Tennessee are settled before they reach the courtroom. That being said, there are situations in which taking a case to trial could be necessary for a successful outcome. The process and implications of out-of-court settlements are important for anyone involved in a personal injury claim to understand.

Get Your FREE Case Review

The Prevalence of Out-of-Court Settlements

Settlements are a common resolution in personal injury cases. They involve the injured party (the plaintiff) agreeing to accept compensation from the at-fault party (the defendant) or their insurance company in exchange for dropping the lawsuit. This process can occur at any stage before the final court verdict.

Advantages of Settling Out of Court

  • Time and Cost Efficiency: Court trials can be lengthy and expensive. Settling out of court typically results in a quicker resolution and can save both parties significant legal fees and court costs.
  • Control and Certainty: Settlements give both parties more control over the outcome. Unlike a trial verdict, which is unpredictable, a settlement is a mutually agreed-upon resolution.
  • Privacy: Court proceedings are public, while settlements can be kept private, which can be beneficial for those who prefer discretion.
  • Reduced Stress: Avoiding the adversarial court process can reduce the emotional and psychological stress often associated with trials.

The Settlement Process in Tennessee

  1. Negotiation: After filing a claim, your attorney will negotiate with the defendant’s insurance company. This involves presenting evidence of negligence and the extent of your injuries and losses.
  2. Mediation: If direct negotiation doesn’t lead to a settlement, the parties might opt for mediation, where a neutral third party helps facilitate a resolution.
  3. Settlement Agreement: Once a settlement amount is agreed upon, a written agreement is drafted. This document outlines the compensation amount and the terms of the settlement, including the relinquishment of future claims related to the injury.
  4. Payment: After the agreement is signed, the defendant or their insurer will process the payment. This typically concludes the legal process.

Situations That May Require a Court Trial

While settling a personal injury claim outside of court is often beneficial for all parties involved, certain circumstances necessitate a trial to ensure justice and fair compensation. These situations include:

  • Disputed Liability: When the at-fault party or their insurance company denies responsibility for the incident, proving liability in court may be necessary. If there’s significant disagreement over who is at fault or the extent to which each party is responsible, a trial provides a platform for presenting evidence and legal arguments to establish liability.
  • Insufficient Settlement Offers: Sometimes, the defendant’s insurance company may offer a settlement that does not adequately cover the victim’s medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering, or other damages. If negotiations fail to yield a fair offer, taking the case to trial can be a way to seek a more appropriate compensation amount.
  • Uncooperative Insurance Companies: Insurance companies may sometimes engage in bad faith practices, such as unreasonably delaying the processing of claims or refusing to pay out legitimate claims. A trial can be necessary to challenge these practices and secure the owed compensation.
  • Public Interest or Policy Change: In some instances, a case might be taken to court to set a legal precedent or to draw attention to issues of public safety and policy. These cases can go beyond individual compensation, aiming to effect change that benefits a broader segment of the public.

Complex Legal Issues: Cases involving complex legal questions or significant interpretations of law might require a court’s intervention. Trials offer a structured environment to address and resolve intricate legal issues that cannot be adequately handled through out-of-court negotiations.

Important Considerations When Settling Outside of Court

When it comes to settling outside of court, there are several important considerations to keep in mind. Here are some key factors to consider:

Fair Compensation & Insurance Company Tactics

Ensure the settlement offer adequately covers all your damages, including medical expenses, lost wages, and pain and suffering. Be wary of early settlement offers from insurance companies, which may not fully compensate you and could bar you from recovering future damages. An experienced attorney can help assess the fairness of an offer and negotiate on your behalf to ensure a fair settlement.

Legal Guidance

Consulting with a personal injury attorney is of the utmost importance. They can guide you through the negotiation process, represent your interests, and help you understand the legal implications of your settlement.

Protect Your Settlement With The McMahan Law Firm

Settling a personal injury claim outside of court is a common and often beneficial approach in Tennessee. It offers a quicker, more controlled, and less stressful resolution compared to a court trial.  The decision to settle or to go to court for a jury award should be based on a careful evaluation of your specific circumstances by a qualified legal professional.

Making your way through this process with the assistance of one of our skilled injury attorneys helps make sure that the settlement reached is fair and compensates you adequately for your injuries and losses.